Sloane thinks her merman boyfriend Caspian abandoned her until his pearl hatches their son, Finn. Five years later, he returns during a hurricane, still wearing his convenience-store uniform and carrying the promised cigarettes. Claiming he was delayed crossing oceans, he offers a treasure-filled shipwreck as a proposal gift. Broke and heartbroken, Sloane must decide whether to forgive him while raising a mischievous merboy who eats live shrimp, transforms in water, and longs for his family.