On a rainy night before closing, a girl clutching an old picture book asks the two men behind the counter, “Which one of you is my dad?” A paternity test turns Adrian into a father overnight, yet he doesn’t even know what his daughter likes. Lucas, who isn’t related by blood, understands her fears better than anyone. These two novice dads start from picking up and dropping off to cooking, hoping to give Nina—a woman always packing her bags—a real home. But when her biological mother and stepfather show up one after another, Lucas begins to waver. Blood ties can prove who’s the father, but they can’t answer the question she fears most: Will you stay?