Vivian Hale and Ethan Shaw were in love. Ethan favored Yvonne Cho, forged a Marriage Certificate, which caused Vivian to suffer a Miscarriage. Ethan was absent from their engagement. Vivian married Zane Carter. At the wedding, Ethan caused a scene, Yvonne exposed the fake certificate and the truth of the Miscarriage. Ethan regretted, Yvonne was sentenced to prison. Ethan lived with regret.