Lucas Moretti, the ruthless heir of a crime family, plays the sweet boy next door for Nathan, the straight bartender he has loved for ten years. Then a sharp-tongued stranger, Evan Cross, claims the center stool at Nathan's bar, and the two rivals end up with guns drawn. Lucas soon discovers his rival is an undercover FBI agent tracking a drug pipeline hidden in Nathan's liquor crates, yet when assassins storm the bar, Evan takes a bullet for him. Then Nathan announces his wedding and asks both heartbroken men to be his groomsmen. At the altar, Lucas's fiancée Bianca exposes his crush on Nathan, and Evan silences the church by claiming Lucas as his own with a kiss. The photo spreads overnight: Evan is suspended, Lucas is forced into an arranged marriage, and rival boss Kessler, who has been smuggling drugs through the Moretti docks, plots to destroy them both. Torn between the badge and the family, Lucas and Evan must decide whether a love built on opposite sides of the law is worth risking everything.
