After a championship party, film student Eli Chen wakes up covered in hickeys, aching all over, with an opened condom wrapper beside his bed—and no memory of the night before. His five champion-athlete roommates each admit to touching or kissing him, but none will reveal the whole truth. As Eli investigates, he discovers they are all hiding the same secret—and they all want him. But when edited footage turns the mystery into a campus scandal, Eli must uncover what really happened, clear their names, and decide whether he has to choose only one.