Penny Paxton is killed by Shaye's sister, Chloe Lennox. Penny's soul travels to ancient times, becoming a Convicted Concubine. Shaye seeks justice for Penny, but her family sides with Chloe and kicks Shaye out. Shaye communicates with Penny via a parrot. Penny sends Shaye a Chamber Pot, which Theodore buys. Shaye and Theodore unite against Chloe at The Treasure Gala. Theodore is from The Hawthorne Family. Shaye helps The Hawthorne Family win, getting justice for Penny.