Aaron never imagined that a simple love poem could turn his secret crush into the biggest rumor at school. He has always admired Connor, the school’s star hockey player, but when the poem he wrote for him is found with only the initials “C.B.,” everyone assumes Aaron is secretly in love with Caleb, the hockey team captain. Things become even more complicated when Aaron is assigned to tutor Caleb. Forced to spend their days together, the two gradually grow closer, and what begins as an innocent misunderstanding soon creates a tension neither of them expected.