Chloe, a plus-size girl, spends a year losing weight to meet Tyler, her online boyfriend—only for him to find her old photos and publicly "transfer" her to strangers. Mocked online, she returns to school transformed, leaving Tyler desperate and regretful. The mysterious buyer of the account is Nathan—the boy she once snuck cookies with at weight-loss camp, now a legendary quarterback. He's gentle, sincere, and loves her for who she's always been. Tyler discovers the truth far too late: Chloe has already chosen the one who loved her exactly as she was.
