For five years, Evan Mercer believed his wife Claire spent Christmas with the parents of her dead first love. Then he hears the truth: Owen is alive, and Claire never stopped loving him. While Evan waits downstairs, she kisses the man everyone thought was buried. The neglected parents, cheap gifts, secret trips, and stolen cash make sense. Evan leaves with one decision: this Christmas will be the last time he waits. But Claire believes he will return. What happens when she learns what he signed?