After catching Ethan cheating, Olivia walks out and ends things for good. To make Ethan regret it, she approaches his half-brother Liam, the school's hockey star. She offers to tutor him in exchange for one thing: he becomes her fake boyfriend. What begins as a deal soon spins out of control. Awkward practice kisses lead to a secret photo of them in the library, and their fake relationship starts to feel dangerously real. Then Ethan sends Olivia a video of Liam kissing another girl six months earlier, determined to break her. At a party, Liam publicly makes it clear that Olivia is his, leaving Ethan humiliated. Later that night, Liam says softly, "What happened earlier... I couldn't fake it." The man in the video was him, but once he uncovers the truth, he promises Olivia answers. Olivia does not press him. She simply follows him.