Trapped in a soul-crushing routine, Gary spends his night shifts enduring relentless bullying from his coworker Amber and unfair criticism from his manager, Madison. His dreary world lights up only when Vanessa, a breathtaking and remarkably kind customer, stops by for a late-night order. But Gary’s hopes are instantly crushed when he watches her drive away in a wealthy older man’s luxury car, convincing him he is destined to be a penniless nobody. Everything changes in a flash when a freak accident at the cash register teleports Gary back in time to the early 1900s American Old West. Stranded as a dirt-poor frontier farmer, Gary must trade his pizza apron for grit, outsmart the lawless wild, and build a new legacy from scratch.