Evan, an overweight college student, works for ruthless mob boss Sabrina. Unable to find her ideal boyfriend, he edits his photos, creates a handsome online persona, and dates her himself. When Sabrina plans to propose, Evan panics, but a call from the wrong phone exposes his lie. She keeps him close, and jealousy, danger, and a near-fatal rescue reveal their true feelings. Evan then learns Sabrina's ideal man was based on him all along, turning their fake online romance into real love.