At 24 years old, Brooke Pearson returned to Seattle after being away from her hometown for many years. On her first night there, her close friend Megan Thornton dragged her from the airport to a party held on a rooftop. The lights were turned off, and everyone picked up their phones; Avery Bennett, a corporate lawyer, took out his wedding ring and asked Jules Thornton, with whom he had broken off his engagement three months earlier, to reconsider their relationship. Before Brooke could even process the chance to meet again as an adult with the person she had had a crush on since childhood, she saw that Jules, despite the pressure from those around them, didn’t look at the ring but instead looked at her first.