Soren deliberately broke up with Rafe to protect both him and his younger brother Eli. A year later, Rafe’s Enigma pheromones spiral out of control, and only Soren’s touch stabilizes him. They sign a medical contact agreement, then unexpectedly reunite on the dating show UNFILTERED. Soren joins for the money; Rafe follows him in. Their past relationship is exposed during filming, and Soren’s stepfather Grant threatens Eli’s safety, demanding $100,000. Rafe insists on documenting everything and calling the police. When the truth comes out, Soren finally admits he left to protect Rafe. In the final choice ceremony, they pick each other. Grant is arrested, Eli is safe, and months later, Rafe proposes on a rainy night. Soren says yes.