As Lakewood High's youngest female principal, Emily Carter starts her new job and meets special students: one boy has repeated senior year for eighty years, listed as 17 but with eyes carrying Revolutionary‑War‑era weariness. The football captain turns feral and howls under every full moon.
Both supernatural figures wreck the cafeteria and parking lot over a human girl, with the whole school hailing it as true love. Emily sees only costly school violence. The vampire progenitor mocks her for failing to grasp eternal love, yet she serves him an expulsion notice, pointing out he also lacks proper school enrollment. When the werewolf leader threatens to destroy the campus, Emily disqualifies his football team for the season.
The two clan heads soon come to apologize. The 800‑year‑old vampire turns in parental permission forms, while the werewolf prince does playground trash duty as punishment. After that, nobody at Lakewood dares claim true love overrides school rules.
