The story follows Lorna, an intelligent, independent and somewhat reserved high-school student who works on her school's newspaper, and Keaton, the popular, charming captain of the school baseball team.
Lorna is dating Julian, a fellow newspaper editor, but their relationship is strained by disagreements over the newspaper's editorial direction. Lorna wants to investigate serious issues such as bullying, while Julian favours more popular stories.
Everything changes at a school party when Lorna discovers Julian has been unfaithful. Furious and heartbroken, she publicly breaks up with him and impulsively kisses Keaton, who happens to be nearby.
The unexpected kiss becomes the catalyst for an unlikely romance.
Initially, Lorna dismisses Keaton as a stereotypical, intellectually shallow athlete, while Keaton is intrigued by the studious girl who suddenly enters his life. Their awkward encounters, misunderstandings and playful exchanges gradually give way to genuine attraction.
