This Time, I Pick the Second

Serena Caldwell successfully married Julian Pierce, but found that he was deeply in love with her sister Lydia Caldwell. After being reborn, she chose to fulfill the two and married Adrian Yates, who was rumored to be disabled and violent. Julian mistakenly believed that Serena still insisted on marrying him, and was used by Lydia to harm Serena multiple times. By the time he realized it was too late to make amends. After marrying Adrian, Serena discovered that he was not a vicious person.