After the Reveal, the Cold Captain Chased Me

Chloe has crippling social anxiety, yet online she's a radiant little sun. Her secret boyfriend Y is Hunter Stone, the merciless football captain who made her do burpees, then declared she's "not his type." He never realizes his online girlfriend is the awkward girl he keeps rejecting. When the truth drops, the ice-cold captain falls to his knees and grovels for a year to win back his shy sunshine.