West Texas good girl and gifted cellist Wren Calloway plans to propose to biker playboy Colt Ransom, only to catch him cheating. Two months after he dumps her, a disastrous blind date with his rival, mafia heir Marlowe Vance, sparks an unexpected romance. Seeing her move on sends Colt into a jealous spiral, and he begs for another chance. But Wren is done being the girl who waits. As old promises clash with a new love, will she choose the man who broke her heart or the one who truly sees her?