Brody, the most popular boy on campus, publicly confesses to his first love Alexis, and everyone thinks it is a perfect fairytale. But then his long-lost pregnant sister Becca returns, bringing back a buried story of pain and revenge. As Alexis and her family try to destroy Becca with reputation and public pressure, Brody is forced to choose between love, family, and the truth. When witnesses, evidence, and old abusers appear one by one, prom night becomes a public trial. In the end, Becca takes back her dignity and future, while Brody finally stops protecting a false first love.
